19
Thursday
April 2018
9:18 PM IST
News Headlines
Nawaz Sharif, daughter leave for London        Former US first lady Barbara Bush dead at 92        Manmohan Singh on Kathua, Unnao rape cases: ‘PM Narendra Modi should follow own advice to me, speak more often’        Kathua rape ‘barbaric’, says President Kovind        KKR breach Rajasthan fortress at Jaipur, beat RR by 7 wickets        Virat Kohli downbeat despite smashing IPL run record        BJP ministers in J&K government asked to resign, to be replaced with new faces        Banks are unable to meet the demand for cash, says ATM industry        India, Sweden to enhance cooperation in defence, cyber security        Castro set to step aside as Cuban president, his reforms incomplete        Mumbai outplay Bangalore in IPL tie        Kolkata Police summons cricketer Mohammed Shami in domestic abuse case        10-man Bengaluru FC thrash Mohun Bagan to set up Super Cup final with East Bengal        Countrywide protests demanding justice in Kathua and Unnao rape cases        Former FBI director James Comey makes shocking claims about Trump        Prince Harry, Meghan Markle to work as Commonwealth youth ambassadors        Manchester City crowned Premier League champions as?Manchester United drop points        IPL-2018: KKR canter to 71-run win over Delhi        Watch Video: Mumbai Indians vs Delhi Daredevils / Pre-match analysis        Putin: attack on Syria act of aggression        
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | About Deepika 
Kerala News
Supreme Court dismisses plea challenging Chief Justice role in allotment of cases
 
A bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra on Wednesday dismissed a plea challenging his prerogative to allot cases and decide composition of benches of the apex court.

Holding that the Chief Justice is at the “helm of the institution” and was conferred with authority under the Constitution to take decisions on allotment of cases, justice D.Y. Chandrachud said, “There should not be a ‘presumption of mistrust’ in the discharge of duties by the chief justice”.

To this effect, the order authored by justice Chandrachud stated, “The oath of the office demands nothing else.”

Reiterating that the Chief Justice was the “master of the roster” and sole authority to decide on allotment of cases, the court held that “in the allocation of cases and the Constitution of benches, the Chief Justice has an exclusive prerogative. As a repository of constitutional trust, the Chief Justice is an institution in himself. The authority is entrusted to the chief justice because such an entrustment of functions is necessary for the efficient transaction of the administrative and judicial work of the court”.

The three-judge bench was hearing a plea by lawyer Asok Pande, seeking a regularized and transparent procedure for allotment of cases that are brought to the top court to different benches.

The petition also sought Constitution benches comprising the five senior-most judges—Chief Justice Dipak Misra and justices J. Chelameswar, Ranjan Gogoi, Madan B. Lokur, Kurian Joseph—or a combination of the three senior-most and two junior-most judges. Similarly, it asked for a three-judge bench to include the chief justice and two senior-most judges.

This request was rejected for lacking constitutional basis and the fact that it would “intrude into the exclusive duty and authority of the chief justice” to constitute benches and allocate cases.

A similar challenge to the allegedly unbridled and exclusive powers of the chief justice brought by advocate and former law minister Shanti Bhushan and lawyer/social activist Prashant Bhushan is pending before the top court.

This is not the first time that the apex court has upheld the powers of the chief justice to decide what case is put before which judge.

In November 2017, a Constitution bench headed by Misra asserted that as Chief Justice, he was the master of the roster and it was his prerogative to assign cases to benches of the apex court.

The verdict assumes significance as it comes in the backdrop of the 12 January press conference of senior judges who raised the issue of improper allocation of cases.

To be sure, a new system for allocation of cases was put in place by chief justice Misra. Under the new roster system, effective 5 February, cases were to be allocated based on the subject matter they entail.

The chief justice would, however, still be vested with a big chunk of important matters including all special leave petitions, and matters related to public interest, social justice, elections, arbitration, and criminal matters.


Hate speech on Kathua rape victim: Case against Kotak Mahindra Bank employee Vishnu Nandakumar
Gang attacks BJP leader in Thiruvananthapuram
Govt doctors on indefinite stir in Kerala
Radio Jockey's murder: Ali Bhai confesses to the crime
BJP protests Varappuzha Sreejith's custody death
Hadiya has "absolute autonomy over her person": SC on love jihad case
Dalit Activists march in Kottayam supporting harthal / Video
Dalit harthal: Here's what political leaders said
M Geethanandan held
State government issues protocol to confirm brain death
Dalit harthal: KSRTC buses attacked, Geethanandan taken into custody / Video
Dalit Aikyavedi calls for hartal on Monday
Percussion expert Padmanabha Marar dead
Govt to conduct 'socio-economic survey' among tribals
Supreme Court nullifies Kerala medical colleges admission bill
Malayalam actor Ajith passes away
Admissions to Kannur, Karuna Medical Colleges regularised
Two-year-old girl drowns after fall from houseboat
State not to forgo additional tax revenue on petro products
Jayasurya's encroachments to be demolished
ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
Women being vocal is still new to the world: Priyanka Chopra
 (New Delhi, Apr 12, 2018): Priyanka Chopra believes that women have started to stand up agai  
Shooting of 'Student of the Year 2' begins in Dehradun
Challenging to play Thackeray, says Nawazuddin Siddiqui
Shah Rukh Khan's wax statue unveiled at Madame Tussauds Delhi
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
Nawaz Sharif, daughter leave for London
 (Islamabad, Apr 18, 2018):Former Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and his daughter Maryam
Former US first lady Barbara Bush dead at 92
India, Sweden to enhance cooperation in defence, cyber security
Castro set to step aside as Cuban president, his reforms incomplete
NATIONAL NEWS
Manmohan Singh on Kathua, Unnao rape cases: ‘PM Narendra Modi should follow own advice to me, speak more often’
 (New Delhi, Apr 18, 2018):Hitting out at Prime Minister Narendra Modi for his long silence ov
Kathua rape ‘barbaric’, says President Kovind
BJP ministers in J&K government asked to resign, to be replaced with new faces
Pakistan violates ceasefire in J-K's Rajouri
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2017 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.