21
Friday
September 2018
12:26 AM IST
News Headlines
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | Health   | About Deepika 
Kerala News
Supreme Court dismisses plea challenging Chief Justice role in allotment of cases
 
A bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra on Wednesday dismissed a plea challenging his prerogative to allot cases and decide composition of benches of the apex court.

Holding that the Chief Justice is at the “helm of the institution” and was conferred with authority under the Constitution to take decisions on allotment of cases, justice D.Y. Chandrachud said, “There should not be a ‘presumption of mistrust’ in the discharge of duties by the chief justice”.

To this effect, the order authored by justice Chandrachud stated, “The oath of the office demands nothing else.”

Reiterating that the Chief Justice was the “master of the roster” and sole authority to decide on allotment of cases, the court held that “in the allocation of cases and the Constitution of benches, the Chief Justice has an exclusive prerogative. As a repository of constitutional trust, the Chief Justice is an institution in himself. The authority is entrusted to the chief justice because such an entrustment of functions is necessary for the efficient transaction of the administrative and judicial work of the court”.

The three-judge bench was hearing a plea by lawyer Asok Pande, seeking a regularized and transparent procedure for allotment of cases that are brought to the top court to different benches.

The petition also sought Constitution benches comprising the five senior-most judges—Chief Justice Dipak Misra and justices J. Chelameswar, Ranjan Gogoi, Madan B. Lokur, Kurian Joseph—or a combination of the three senior-most and two junior-most judges. Similarly, it asked for a three-judge bench to include the chief justice and two senior-most judges.

This request was rejected for lacking constitutional basis and the fact that it would “intrude into the exclusive duty and authority of the chief justice” to constitute benches and allocate cases.

A similar challenge to the allegedly unbridled and exclusive powers of the chief justice brought by advocate and former law minister Shanti Bhushan and lawyer/social activist Prashant Bhushan is pending before the top court.

This is not the first time that the apex court has upheld the powers of the chief justice to decide what case is put before which judge.

In November 2017, a Constitution bench headed by Misra asserted that as Chief Justice, he was the master of the roster and it was his prerogative to assign cases to benches of the apex court.

The verdict assumes significance as it comes in the backdrop of the 12 January press conference of senior judges who raised the issue of improper allocation of cases.

To be sure, a new system for allocation of cases was put in place by chief justice Misra. Under the new roster system, effective 5 February, cases were to be allocated based on the subject matter they entail.

The chief justice would, however, still be vested with a big chunk of important matters including all special leave petitions, and matters related to public interest, social justice, elections, arbitration, and criminal matters.


Bar bribery case: Court dismisses the vigilance report
State Kalolsavam to be held in December
Actor Captain Raju passes away at 68
Hartal affected normal lives
Petrol, diesel prices hiked again today
Kerala likely to face power shortage: M.M. Mani
Petrol, diesel prices go up
Petrol, diesel prices go up
World Bank team to visit Kerala soon
Kerala floods: State calls off IFFK, Kalolsavam
Ready to face any investigation: P.K. Sasi MLA
Scare-mongering: Case filed against Jacob Vadakkanchery
Hanaan injured in a car accident
Seven including four Keralites killed in a bus accident
Government extends deadline to file Income Tax returns in Kerala
Metro Man Sreedharan Says Getting Foreign Aid for Kerala Not a Matter of Pride
Kerala flood very big tragedy, we are all with you, says Rahul Gandhi
Mass cleaning mission begins at Kuttanad
Pinarayi mass murder accused commits suicide at Women's prison
Kuthiran tunnel to be opened partially
ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
Viswasam- On set photos leaked
 A few photos from the set of Ajith's Viswasam is going viral on social media. The photos show Ajith  
Aiswarya- Abhishek's Gulab Jamun would go on floor in mid 2019
Varun and Anushka signed as ambassadors of Skill India Campaign
Madhuri, Alia, Varun and to share screen
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
Palestinian schools strive to modernize classrooms
 Ramallah, Sep 19 (AP) As the teacher pointed to the large touch screen, her first-grade classroom ca
Trump: Declassified Russia probe papers expose 'bad things'
100 die in severe flooding in Nigeria: relief agency
Pak govt, Opposition agree for parliamentary probe into vote rigging charges
NATIONAL NEWS
CAT 2018: Registration extended to Sept 26; Admit card to Release on Oct 24
 CAT is one of the most sought after exam in the country for candidates possessing a Bachelor’s degre
2 history-sheeters arrested following encounter: Police
Attack on Cong workers in Chhattisgarh is political persecution: Rahul Gandhi
Instant Triple Talaq to be criminal offence
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2018 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.